Politics
How can Nepal’s Parliament impeach Supreme Court judges?
The Rastriya Swatantra Party has instructed its parliamentary wing to act over alleged misconduct in the judiciary. Here is how the Constitution and parliamentary rules govern the impeachment process.Jaya Singh Mahara
The ruling Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP) has instructed its parliamentary wing to begin the process of addressing what it describes as irregularities in the judiciary. The move has raised questions about when and how the party intends to act against Supreme Court justices facing allegations of misconduct, including through impeachment.
RSP chair Rabi Lamichhane has been holding discussions on how the party should pursue judicial reform. Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Sobita Gautam, who is also an RSP vice-chair, said the party secretariat had decided to consult various stakeholders through its parliamentary wing before taking further steps.
“The party chair has held discussions with lawmakers who have a legal background, and I was among those who took part. The issue was also discussed by the party secretariat. The chair has been consulting legal experts and respected figures in society who are sympathetic to the party, while other party leaders have also been discussing it,” Gautam said.
“The discussions have led us to conclude that the judiciary is not functioning as it should. After the political change, there was an expectation that reforms would take place across institutions, including the judiciary. But longstanding problems within the courts have now come into the open.
“The situation has reached a point where judges themselves are reportedly seeking out people described as middlemen. That is why we believe action is needed to clean up the judiciary.”
Asked when the party would initiate parliamentary proceedings, Gautam said no decision had been made on whether to convene a special session or wait for the regular session.
“There is only a week left before the Tihar holidays, and there are procedural and logistical considerations involved in convening Parliament. It seems unlikely that circumstances will require a special session specifically for judicial reform, so the process will probably move forward during the regular session,” she said.
The latest controversy involving the judiciary centres on Supreme Court Justice Hari Prasad Phuyal, who reportedly exchanged WhatsApp messages with alleged fixer Inam Sapkota about a case and later met him at a hotel. The issue has fuelled calls for judicial reform from RSP leaders and lawmakers with a legal background. The party, which secured nearly a two-thirds majority in the House of Representatives in the March 5 election, had also raised the issue during Parliament’s budget session.
As dissatisfaction among ruling party leaders over the judiciary grew, reports emerged of Phuyal’s meeting with Sapkota. The justice has acknowledged meeting him. Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Sharma has also been linked to Sapkota following reports of a financial transaction in which Sapkota deposited money into Sharma’s bank account.
Phuyal has partly acknowledged the allegations concerning his dealings with Sapkota, but Sharma has categorically denied them. The Supreme Court subsequently held a full court meeting, but the controversy deepened rather than subsided.
The RSP leadership also began taking a more active interest in the dispute. On Friday, Lamichhane held discussions with Gautam and lawmakers with a legal background on whether impeachment or other constitutional and legal mechanisms could be used to address the reported problems within the Supreme Court. After receiving suggestions that the issues should be resolved through established constitutional and legal procedures, Lamichhane convened a meeting of the RSP secretariat.
At its meeting on Saturday, the RSP discussed the Supreme Court controversy at length and decided to pursue action against irregularities in the judiciary.
“Serious instances of misconduct and improper dealings involving some judges have raised grave questions about the judiciary’s impartiality, neutrality, and institutional integrity. These developments reinforce the need for judicial reform and accountability...,” the party said in its decision. “The parliamentary wing has been directed to take decisive action through Parliament, in accordance with established procedures, and bring the matter to a conclusive resolution.”
How the parliamentary wing will act on the directive remains to be seen. Ganesh Parajuli, a member of the party secretariat and deputy leader of the RSP parliamentary party, said any action would be in line with the Constitution, laws, House of Representatives regulations, and parliamentary practices.
“If necessary, we will seek an early session of Parliament to move the process forward. This is not about targeting any particular individual, but about addressing irregularities in the judiciary through constitutional and legal procedures.”
Constitutional provisions about impeaching Supreme Court judges
Article 101(2) of the constitution provides for the impeachment of the chief justice and other Supreme Court justices. If the grounds for impeachment are established, the person concerned is removed from office.
The Constitution allows one-fourth of the total number of members of the House of Representatives to register an impeachment motion against the chief justice, a Supreme Court justice, a member of the Judicial Council or the head or an office-holder of a constitutional body.
The grounds include serious violations of the Constitution or the law, incompetence, misconduct, failure to perform official duties honestly, or serious violations of the code of conduct that make the person unable to discharge their responsibilities.
An impeachment motion must secure the support of at least two-thirds of the total number of sitting members of the House of Representatives to pass. Once approved, the person concerned is removed from office.
The process is governed by Rule 164 of the House of Representatives Regulations, 2026. Anyone seeking to file an impeachment motion against the chief justice or Supreme Court justices must submit a notice to the secretary general of Parliament, or to the secretary in the secretary general’s absence, stating the grounds and reasons for the proposed motion.
If Parliament is not in session, the motion must be accompanied by a request to summon a session within 15 days. Once received, the motion is submitted to the Speaker.
If the House is in session, the motion must be scheduled for discussion within 15 days of its registration. If Parliament is not in session, it is taken up at the first meeting of the session convened following the request. As the House is currently not in session, an impeachment motion filed immediately would require Parliament to be summoned. If it is registered after the regular session begins, the process will proceed during that session.
The Speaker sets the date and time for discussion. Following the debate, the motion is referred to the Impeachment Recommendation Committee.
Can citizens also initiate the process?
The Constitution provides another route for initiating impeachment proceedings, beyond a motion filed directly by one-fourth of House members.
Under Article 101(5), information, reports or complaints alleging grounds for impeachment can be submitted by individuals other than lawmakers. However, at least three members of the House must verify and endorse the submission before it can proceed.
The grounds must involve serious violations of the Constitution, incompetence, misconduct, failure to perform official duties honestly or serious breaches of the code of conduct.
The Impeachment Recommendation Committee established under Article 101(3) is responsible for investigating whether sufficient grounds exist to recommend an impeachment motion. The Constitution provides for an 11-member committee comprising House members.
Under the House regulations, a complaint endorsed by at least three lawmakers is referred to the committee for investigation. If the committee recommends impeachment after examining the complaint, a formal motion can be presented to the House.
Rule 165 of the House of Representatives Regulations governs the formation of the 11-member Impeachment Recommendation Committee. The Speaker proposes its formation after consulting the Business Advisory Committee of the House. Members of the committee elect a chairperson from among themselves.
How does the committee investigate?
Once formed, the committee is required to begin its work without delay. It must give the person facing allegations an opportunity to defend themselves within seven days.
Whether or not the accused submits a defence, the committee must prepare a report with its recommendation and present it to the House.
The regulations require the committee to submit its report within three months of beginning its proceedings. The report must then be distributed to all members of the House.
Rule 168 sets out the procedure for considering the committee's report. The Speaker determines when it will be discussed. The committee chairperson or another member may table a motion seeking consideration of the report, after which the House debates its findings.
A member may also propose sending the report back to the committee for further investigation. If the House approves such a motion by a majority, the committee must conduct a fresh investigation and submit a revised report within seven days.
The committee chairperson, or another member in the chairperson’s absence, presents the report to the House. Members may propose amendments, which are also discussed before the House proceeds to a vote.
The House decides on an impeachment motion through a recorded division, with members’ signatures attached to their votes.
For impeachment to pass, it must secure the support of two-thirds of the House's total membership of 275, or at least 184 votes. If the motion passes, the chief justice or justice concerned is removed from office.
The secretary general of Parliament, or the secretary in their absence, must inform the President, the Council of Ministers and the office-holder concerned of the House's decision.
What happens after impeachment?
Removal through impeachment does not shield the individual from criminal prosecution. The Constitution allows legal action to be taken for any offence committed while the person held office.
Anyone removed through impeachment also loses the right to benefits attached to the office and becomes ineligible for appointment or nomination to any public office in the future.
Does the RSP have enough votes?
Parliamentary arithmetic will be crucial if the RSP moves ahead with an impeachment motion against the chief justice or another Supreme Court justice.
The ruling party currently has 182 seats in the House of Representatives. However, Speaker DP Aryal, who was elected from the RSP, cannot participate in the vote on an impeachment motion. This leaves the party with 181 votes.
If independent lawmaker Mahabir Pun, who is also a minister, supports the RSP’s proposal, the number could rise to 182. Even then, the party would fall short of the 184 votes required to pass an impeachment motion.
The story has been updated.




22.12°C Kathmandu







.png&w=300&height=200)







