Culture & Lifestyle
Why Nepali cinema can’t stop playing ‘blame the buhari’
A pattern in recent films casts women’s ambitions as threats to family harmony, reinforcing familiar stereotypes.Samarpan Shree & Arati Paudel
In Deepak Acharya’s recently released film ‘Paran’, an ageing father wants one thing: for his younger son to stay. The son, played by Mahesh Tripathi,does not want to leave his parents either. His wife has other plans. Hoping for a more comfortable life in the United States, she presses him, again and again to apply for the Diversity Visa lottery. He eventually gives in. When the couple leaves, the father, played by Neer Shah, is left to face a very different life.
The film captures the loneliness of ageing parents. But when it reaches for a cause, it points at the daughter-in-law. The son’s own decision, the family’s economic and social circumstances, and the differing expectations of two generations receive far less attention.
‘Paran’ is not an outlier. A son marries, the family frays, and the wife is held responsible. It has become one of Nepali cinema’s most familiar plots.
In Hari Lamsal’s ‘Ba: Ek Yoddha’, released in August, Rudra Prasad, played by Divya Dev Pant, gives his daughter the land title deed as a wedding gift, angering his son and daughter-in-law. The latter is portrayed as turning her husband against his parents and pushing him to move abroad. Even his harsh treatment of his father is framed as her influence.
Chandra Panta’s ‘Aa Bata Aama 2’, released on October 16, follows Devaki (Bipana Thapa), whose happy family comes undone when her son moves to Australia, a decision the film attributes largely to his wife’s insistence. When the couple has a child, Devaki too is left with little choice but to follow. The daughter-in-law’s self-interest and lack of concern are portrayed as the driving forces behind the family’s troubles, casting her as the villain.
In Dipendra Lama’s ‘Chha Maya Chhapakkai-2’, released during Dashain, Muralidhar (Deepak Raj Giri) is caught between his wife (Keki Adhikari), who wants a more comfortable life abroad, and his father, who wants him to stay in the village and pursue politics. It is the wife’s ambitions that set the family conflict in motion. In Gyanendra Deuja’s ‘Jhingedau-2’, released in August, the rivalry of two daughters-in-law drives a wedge between two brothers, eventually forcing their mother to leave the family home. In Dinesh Raut’s ‘Mahabhoj’, released in January, the wife is once again cast as the source of family discord. Bishnu (Khagendra Lamichhane) faces pressure from his wife (Anjana Baraili) to repay a loan he took from his father-in-law. Her hostile behaviour pushes him further from his family.
The pattern is hard to miss. In each film, a woman’s ambitions and disagreements are the source of discord. The films rarely ask why sons choose to move out, what their wives want for themselves, or whether family expectations leave them any room to decide. Household power dynamics, money worries and a family’s future to talk to one another stay in the background.
Some films simply swap the villain. In Kapil Rijal’s ‘Gaunthali’, released in July, a mother-in-law rules the household and abuses her daughter-in-law. She remains a negative figure throughout, feeding another familiar trope: women as each other’s adversaries within the family.

Why this keeps happening
Women’s rights activist Rita Sah says screen portrayals reflect the patriarchal attitudes prevalent in society. Television serials, she notes, routinely depicted women as villains within their own homes. “Films reflect how women are viewed in society,” she says, “But that does not mean such portrayals reflect reality.”
Sah also argues that who writes and directs female characters matters.
Screenwriter Sampada Malla traces part of the habit to Hindi television serials. Writing has never been given the importance it deserves, she says, which lets filmmakers fall back on stereotypes.
“Every character, whether male or female, needs careful development. But writing has never been given the importance it deserves. We keep portraying women this way because we assume that is what audiences want,” she says.
Malla says stronger character development and a better understanding of what drives people’s choices would help filmmakers move beyond simplistic portrayals of men and women as either heroes or villains.
Citing Abinash Bikram Shah’s ‘Elephants in the Fog’, she says filmmakers should give characters more convincing shades of grey. “There was a time when heroes were portrayed as entirely good and villains as entirely bad. Giving characters shades of grey would help break away from that convention,” she says.
Actor Reecha Sharma points to who is telling the stories. With most films written and produced by men, she says, stories tend to emerge from a male perspective. “Our society tends to see men as the natural heroes and the good guys. So filmmakers often find it easier to make women the villains to drive the story,” she says.
Society accepts women who are self-sacrificing and forgiving, she adds, but still views independent, ambitious and self-confident women negatively. South Asian cinema, she says, tends either to idealise women or cast them as villains.
“Cinema will not change until we challenge the belief that a woman’s place is in the home and that household responsibilities are hers alone, even when both partners work,” she says.
Film theory has a name for this. British film theorist Laura Mulvey coined the “male gaze” in 1975 to describe how conventional cinema presents women through a male perspective, reducing them to objects rather than active characters with agency. Women’s desires, choices and struggles are often pushed into the background.

Actor and filmmaker Rekha Thapa has tried to flip the script. In her films, women lead, and she has even turned the familiar hero-rescues-heroine formula on its head, with female protagonists fighting to save male characters.
“In my films, women take the lead. They are the heroes, not characters to be sidelined,” she says. Male filmmakers naturally reflect the world they see, Thapa argues, and women must tell their own stories, as men long have. More women writing, directing and producing films would bring fresh perspectives to Nepali cinema.
The filmmakers’ defence
The film directors claim they draw their characters from the realities of their society and have no intention of vilifying women.
Acharya says ‘Paran’ balances its female character. “Nepali society has been built on patriarchal thinking for centuries. So, when those stories are reflected in films, it is natural for them to depict the character of society and the role of women,” he says. “In Paran, I have tried to balance the female character by showing how a woman thinks more responsibly than a man about her family and her children’s future.”
Lamsal says the daughter-in-law in ‘Ba: Ek Yoddha’ was not deliberately made to look bad. “When she is at her maternal home, she lives freely. But after marriage, she has to fulfil the role of a daughter-in-law amid longstanding social customs, pressure from her in-laws and societal expectations. In that role, she cannot openly express some of her disagreements. Her inner turmoil and dissatisfaction then manifest as a little sharpness in her behaviour,” he explains.
He recalls thinking while writing that a negative daughter-in-law would be a cliché. But, “while creating conflict in the story, the daughter-in-law character ended up being portrayed negatively due to the circumstances,” he admits.

What the stories miss
Sociologist Menuka KC says the films also miss how families are changing. More married sons now move out to set up separate households with their wives, yet when families split, the women are still blamed.
“In the past, men had little role in household work, leaving women to shoulder most domestic responsibilities. This often fuelled tensions between mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law. Today, more married sons are setting up separate homes with their wives. Yet when families split, women are still held responsible,” she says.
Generational divides, changing lifestyles and domestic conflicts are real features of Nepali society, she says, but blaming them on one character’s behaviour or self-interest oversimplifies the issues and risks reinforcing the very prejudices that shape such portrayals.
Some Nepali filmmakers have taken a different approach, putting women’s experiences and choices at the heart of their stories. Binod Poudel’s ‘Bulbul’, Dipendra K Khanal’s ‘Chiso Maanchhe’, and Upendra Subba’s ‘Jaari’ give space to women’s struggles and decisions. Triveni Rai’s ‘Shape of Momo’, a Nepali-language film released this year, also centres on a daughter who challenges the belief that women are weak.
But a woman taking the lead does not, by itself, make a film progressive. Unless female characters are given the same complexity as their male counterparts, filmmakers risk replacing one stereotype with another. Screenwriter Malla says Nepali cinema needs to move beyond its simplistic divide between good and bad characters.
“We have long treated heroes as entirely good and villains as entirely bad. Characters need to have shades of grey.”




22.12°C Kathmandu
















