National
Supreme Court seeks government explanation over Dan Bahadur Karki’s removal as police chief
Lawyers representing the former inspector general sought an interim order reinstating him, arguing that the government had unlawfully removed him before the end of his fixed tenure.Durga Dulal
The Supreme Court on Wednesday ordered the government to explain its decision to remove Dan Bahadur Karki as inspector general of Nepal Police and called both sides for a hearing on his petition challenging the move.
A single bench of Justice Shreekanta Poudel issued the show-cause order after hearing arguments from lawyers representing Karki, who sought an interim order reinstating him as police chief.
Senior advocates argued that the government could not arbitrarily transfer or remove the inspector general, whose appointment carries a fixed tenure. They cited two precedents in support of their case: the removal of former police chief Achyut Krishna Kharel and the case involving Hitendra Dev Shakya, former executive director of the Nepal Electricity Authority.
Opening the arguments, advocate Tika Bahadur Kunwar, president of the Special Court Bar Association Nepal, said the government’s decision was unsupported by the Nepal Police Act, the Constitution or any other law. He urged the court to issue an interim order allowing Karki to resume his duties immediately.
“Karki was removed without any stated reason or even being asked for an explanation. The government arbitrarily removed him with 18 months of his tenure still remaining,” Kunwar told the court.
He also argued that the government had acted with improper intent by appointing Karki as the prime minister’s security adviser as a means of removing him from the police leadership. He described the decision as unlawful on its face.
Senior advocate Madhav Kumar Basnet, who argued next, said the government’s own appointment letter for Karki as security adviser described him as an honest officer who had remained focused on his duties. This, he argued, undermined any justification for removing him as police chief.
Basnet said the law did not envisage transferring an inspector general simply by offering a position with equivalent benefits. He therefore called for an interim order.
Senior advocate Satish Krishna Kharel also argued that an official appointed for a fixed term could not be removed without valid grounds. He said Karki had neither been given a reason for his removal nor asked to explain himself.
“The appointment letter itself shows that the decision was flawed. He has not even served half of his tenure, and there are no grounds for removing him as inspector general,” Kharel said. Citing the precedents involving Nawaraj Silwal and Hitendra Dev Shakya, he urged the court to issue an interim order without delay.
At its November 4 meeting, the Cabinet decided to remove Karki as inspector general and appoint him as a special adviser to the prime minister. It also decided to appoint Manoj Kumar KC as the new police chief.
Karki subsequently moved the Supreme Court, seeking reinstatement and challenging the government's decision. Wednesday’s hearing was the first judicial consideration of his petition.




21.12°C Kathmandu






.png&w=300&height=200)








