Login

Forget Password?
Login With Facebook
Don't Have An Account? Sign Up

Sign Up

Already Have An Account? Login
Read Our Privacy Policy
Back to Login
  • National
  • Politics
  • Valley
  • Opinion
  • Money
  • Sports
  • Culture & Lifestyle

  • National
    • Madhesh Province
    • Lumbini Province
    • Bagmati Province
    • National Security
    • Koshi Province
    • Gandaki Province
    • Karnali Province
    • Sudurpaschim Province
  • Politics
  • Valley
    • Kathmandu
    • Lalitpur
    • Bhaktapur
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • As it is
    • Letters
    • Editorial
    • Cartoon
  • Money
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • International Sports
  • Culture & Lifestyle
    • Arts
    • Brunch with the Post
    • Movies
    • Life & Style
    • Theater
    • Entertainment
    • Books
    • Fashion
  • Health
  • Food
    • Recipes
  • Travel
  • Investigations
  • Climate & Environment
  • World
  • Science & Technology
  • Interviews
  • Visual Stories
  • Crosswords & Sudoku
  • Horoscope
  • Forex
  • Corrections
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Today's ePaper
Wednesday, July 30, 2025

Without Fear or FavourUNWIND IN STYLE

26.61°C Kathmandu
Air Quality in Kathmandu: 70
300+Hazardous
0-50Good
51-100Moderate
101-150Unhealty for Sensitive Groups
151-200Unhealthy
201-300Very Unhealthy
Wed, Jul 30, 2025
26.61°C Kathmandu
Air Quality in Kathmandu: 70
  • What's News :

  • Nepal’s plan to lower marriage age
  • Nepal’s export boom
  • Nepal-India boundary works
  • Maternal deaths in Nepal
  • Division in Maoist Centre

Editorial

Most constitutional bodies remain largely non-functional

NHRC established that the killing of Kumar Paudel was extrajudicial in nature, but the government and the Nepal Police have yet to implement its recommendations. Most constitutional bodies remain largely non-functional
 Shutterstock
bookmark
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • Whatsapp
  • mail
Published at : December 27, 2019
Updated at : December 29, 2019 11:45

In October, the National Human Rights Commission had concluded that Kumar Paudel, Sarlahi district in-charge of the Netra Bikram Chand-led Communist Party of Nepal, was ‘killed after he was taken into custody’. Following controversy over Paudel’s death, the government formed an inquiry team led by an under-secretary at the Ministry of Home Affairs. The inquiry concluded that Paudel had opened fire on police personnel first. But two months since the Commission established that the killing of Paudel was extrajudicial in nature, the government and the Nepal Police have yet to implement its recommendations, showing utter disregard for the constitutional body.

Paudel was killed on June 20 in Lalbandi, Sarlahi district, in what police had claimed was ‘police action’. According to Superintendent of Police Gopal Chandra Bhattarai, security personnel returned fire after a group of four motorcycle-borne persons began shooting at a police patrol. Home Minister Ram Bahadur Thapa restated Bhattarai’s claims before the House of Representatives and the parliamentary State Affairs Committee that Paudel had been killed after police fired in self-defence.

The law says that since the National Human Rights Commission is a constitutional rights watchdog, the government must implement its recommendation within two months or report to it if it fails to do so. But so far, the government has remained passive. What’s more, the Home Ministry and the Nepal Police have not given a clear answer to why the recommendations were not implemented.

Constitutional commissions are created so that they can address important issues pertaining to social inclusion and justice. They are especially mandated to identify areas of necessary policy, legal and institutional reforms, and make recommendations to the government. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the Commission of Investigation on Enforced Disappeared Persons, National Women’s Commission, Dalit Commission and Muslim Commission are a few other commissions the government has created, to name a few.

But successive governments at different times have turned them into a political playground. The conflict over the sharing of positions among the parties and groups within them is the reason behind the delay in appointing members to the commissions. With no members, no human resources and lack of office space, most commissions have remained largely non-functional.

The national commissions are supposed to be parastatal watchdogs to keep an eye on the implementation of human rights and civil liberties. But today, they remain quasi-autonomous bodies with the government pulling the strings. No doubt, such a situation where the commissions are rendered toothless is detrimental to the health of democracy. The fact that the government and the Nepal Police alike need to take the recommendations of the Nepal Human Rights Commission on the Kumar Paudel case seriously cannot be overstated. As it is, many decisions, such as those pertaining to muzzling dissent, or the rise in cases of police brutality during the Oli-led government, have become quite unpopular among the people. Given that, the government must rethink its decisions and act in the interest of the people, and serve the people rather than exploit the system and weaken constitutional bodies. 


Read Other Opinions

Mind the mines
Worth another shot
Parched for ideas
Going wrong on rights
Old fox wins again
Year of broken promises

Most Read from Editorial

Inhumane tradition
Old fox wins again
Going wrong on rights
Maze of scandals
Tech traps

Editor's Picks

Kailash pilgrims breathe new life into Nepal’s mountain economy
Pressure groups are dictating lawmaking
Indians paying by QR in Nepal for a year but Nepalis still lack access in India
UML weighs binning age, term limits amid Oli-Bhandari rivalry
Law in the works to check officials’ conflict of interest

E-PAPER | July 30, 2025

  • Read ePaper Online
×
ABOUT US
  • About the Post
  • Masthead
  • Editorial Standards & Integrity
  • Workplace Harassment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
READ US
  • Home Delivery
  • ePaper
CONTACT US
  • Write for the Post
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Advertise in the Post
  • Work for the Post
  • Send us a tip
INTERACT WITH US
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
OUR SISTER PUBLICATIONS
  • eKantipur
  • saptahik
  • Nepal
  • Nari
  • Radio Kantipur
  • Kantipur TV
© 2025 www.kathmandupost.com
  • Privacy Policy
Top