National
Supreme Court to hear Karki’s petition against removal on Wednesday
The former police chief has challenged the Cabinet’s decision to remove him and appoint Manoj Kumar KC as inspector general, arguing that the move was unlawful.Post Report
The Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing for Wednesday on a writ petition filed by former Nepal Police chief Dan Bahadur Karki challenging the government’s decision to remove him from the post and appoint him prime minister’s special security adviser.
Karki filed the petition on November 6, seeking to overturn the Cabinet decision to transfer him to the newly created advisory post and appoint Manoj Kumar KC as inspector general. He has also sought an interim order preventing KC from exercising the powers of police chief until the court delivers its final verdict.
In his petition, Karki argues that the government removed him before the end of his tenure without citing any legal provision that authorised the transfer of a serving inspector general to a position outside the police organisation. Neither the Police Act 1955 nor the Police Regulations 2014 provides for such a transfer, he says.
Karki has also cited two Supreme Court precedents to support his claim. One concerns former police chief Achyut Krishna Kharel, who was removed in 1997, just 36 days after taking office. The Supreme Court had ruled that the government's decision to transfer Kharel and appoint another police chief lacked a proper basis and appeared politically motivated. The court also warned that arbitrary changes in police leadership could undermine the force's morale, professional independence and effectiveness.
The second precedent involves former Nepal Electricity Authority executive director Hitendra Dev Shakya, who was transferred to an expert member's position at the Water and Energy Commission. The Supreme Court had held that appointing an official to another position and removing them from their existing post were legally distinct actions. Karki argues that the government cannot effectively remove him from the police chief's position simply by assigning him another role without his consent.
He has further argued that the government violated the principles of natural justice by removing him without informing him of the reasons, seeking an explanation or giving him an opportunity to respond. He says he learned about the decision through the media before receiving an official letter from the Ministry of Home Affairs.
The petition also challenges the government's reliance on Section 9(2) of the Police Act, which places police personnel's tenure at the government's discretion. Citing the Supreme Court's ruling in the Kharel case, Karki argues that the provision cannot be used to justify arbitrary removal of a serving inspector general.
Besides seeking the annulment of the Cabinet decisions to remove him and appoint KC, Karki has asked the court to restore him to the post for the remainder of his tenure, along with his previous status, salary, allowances and other service benefits. He has also sought an order preventing the government from removing or transferring him before the end of his tenure without following the prescribed legal procedures.
The court may issue an interim order suspending the implementation of the Cabinet decision or seek an explanation from the government before deciding whether to grant interim relief. The outcome of Wednesday's hearing will determine whether KC can continue exercising the powers of inspector general while the case proceeds.




20.12°C Kathmandu





.png&w=300&height=200)








